tools for calculating volume
I have been experimenting with certain tools to calculate the volume of water in potential dam sites. I have been using the 'pile volume' tool which gives an array of feature information including varied data on volume. when I calculate the volumes using mathematical formula I get a very different answer than that given by the pile volume data.
Is this tool accurate and reliable for this type of calculation? Is anyone using this tool for the same purpose? Can anyone shed some light on why there is so much variation in calculation methods?
Many Thanks
Bruce Kirk
Is this tool accurate and reliable for this type of calculation? Is anyone using this tool for the same purpose? Can anyone shed some light on why there is so much variation in calculation methods?
Many Thanks
Bruce Kirk
Answers

I would create a flat surface by drawing an area and setting its elevation to represent your dam water level, and then use the analysis tab  "measure volume between surfaces" to calculate the void between  always seems to work for me. Ive never used the pile calc method. If you reckon your units are doing something odd, you can control their behaviour in the unit display box here....

coelodonta , but automatically interpolates the second surface using the area feature.
In this case the top of the dam surface would be an interpolated surface using the selected dam boundary area feature as the surface edge, and adding an additional 200 sample points along that border in addition to the existing feature vertices.
This is a convenient way to estimate what the surface was like before the pile or hole existed.
You may also want to look at the volume measurement tool itself, as just setting an explicit defined base height as the water level. 
curves said:I have been experimenting with certain tools to calculate the volume of water in potential dam sites. I have been using the 'pile volume' tool which gives an array of feature information including varied data on volume. when I calculate the volumes using mathematical formula I get a very different answer than that given by the pile volume data.
Is this tool accurate and reliable for this type of calculation? Is anyone using this tool for the same purpose? Can anyone shed some light on why there is so much variation in calculation methods?
Many Thanks
Bruce Kirk
My current work flow using Global Mapper involves:
1: Generating the contour map using the DEM and creating an area feature of the reservoir at the desired contour elevation.
_{}^{}2: Select the area feature and initiate the volume command
3: Choose the "Perform multiple calculations over a range of base heights" and enter the lowest and highest elevations within the area (425 to 440 as shown), then press "OK".
4: The results are shown below with the highest "fill volume" highlighted as 13,285,150m3.
5: You can copy to clipboard and paste to MS Excel to generate graphs live below.
6: If you want to have a more direct volume computation, just do step 1  2 and choose "Use same base height value for all vertices", enter the desired elevation (440 here) and ensure the value is selected as "above sea level".
7: Voila, the fill volume is same.
I have verified this with the manual method and the volumes are not significantly off.

Our company would find a dedicated tool for this very useful in our offices across the world. For instance, placing a point and getting global mapper to fill within the 'basin' to a specific elevation. We perform a lot of analysis for Tailings Facilities so having the ability to model a dam and then compute the capacity behind it would be awesome.
On that subject, having the ability to create a dam from a Line Feature would also be amazing too. We would need to enter the crest width, crest elevation and upstream and downstream slope parameters. 
Great, Thanks Coelodonta, Katrina, allienyouth, and Sphillips, really appreciate the feedback. Lots of methods to investigate.

Greate.
i have a pre Solutions problem, do you have any sugestion?
i have a dem and point cloud with a dam, but i only have the water surface, (survey done with drone) what will be the best workflow to try to simulate the natural terrain under the water level and try to calculate the volume approximate stored water. trying to use the average slope of the main waterline and slopes of the surrounding land.
Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
 12.2K All Categories
 5.3K Features Discussion
 312 Downloading Imagery
 1.2K Elevation Data
 371 Georeferencing Imagery Discussion
 580 GM Script Language
 42 User Scripts
 111 GPS Features
 388 Projection Questions
 788 Raster Data
 1.3K Vector Data
 6.4K Support
 159 Announcement and News
 881 Bug Report
 554 SDK
 1.1K Suggestion Box
 3.6K Technical Support
 520 Other Discussion
 125 GIS Data Sources
 26 Global Mapper Showcase
 217 How I use Global Mapper
 99 Global Mapper Forum Website