Avoiding power poles, power lines, and building edges when classifying points or extracting trees
I have a point cloud that came classified but the classifications were not that great and included a lot of points in wrong classes. For example the high vegetation classification includes a lot of power lines, power poles, and building perimeters. So I decided to clear the classifications and reclassify using GMv21. However I get similar results to the previous classifications, with the high veg including a lot of power line/poles.
This means when i extract trees i am getting long lines of "tree points" where it is actually a power line and no trees exist (confirmed via google street view). The point cloud is not dense enough to properly do a power line auto classification, or so the dialog box in GM tells me, it needs 20 points/m^2 whereas i have 13. So I can't classify power features and separate them out that way.
So looking for suggestions of how to get tree points out without a bunch of power poles and building edges showing up as trees? I thought of using the intensity value to differentiate between a power pole and a tree but not sure how that would happen or that is a good approach.
This means when i extract trees i am getting long lines of "tree points" where it is actually a power line and no trees exist (confirmed via google street view). The point cloud is not dense enough to properly do a power line auto classification, or so the dialog box in GM tells me, it needs 20 points/m^2 whereas i have 13. So I can't classify power features and separate them out that way.
So looking for suggestions of how to get tree points out without a bunch of power poles and building edges showing up as trees? I thought of using the intensity value to differentiate between a power pole and a tree but not sure how that would happen or that is a good approach.
Tagged:
Answers
-
Here is a screenshot to show the issue. The red circled point cluster is a tree that did not get identified as a tree though it meets the extraction criteria (over 2m tall, etc.) the blue circled points are all power lines that get interpreted as trees, and there's a power pole in there too, but I don't see why a power line that is just a handful of points can get considered a tree while a dense cluster (red circle) is not considered a tree.
Categories
- 12.6K All Categories
- 5.5K Features Discussion
- 337 Downloading Imagery
- 1.3K Elevation Data
- 379 Georeferencing Imagery Discussion
- 620 GM Script Language
- 52 User Scripts
- 113 GPS Features
- 405 Projection Questions
- 815 Raster Data
- 1.3K Vector Data
- 6.5K Support
- 171 Announcement and News
- 897 Bug Report
- 558 SDK
- 1.2K Suggestion Box
- 3.7K Technical Support
- 559 Other Discussion
- 129 GIS Data Sources
- 27 Global Mapper Showcase
- 231 How I use Global Mapper
- 106 Global Mapper Forum Website